Oh my god, Eternal Selach is finally done! It is impressive and deserves my upvote, but I have to say:
- Why the rewrite? Imperial Sharks in its original form was a decent and well-liked article. It showed a clever and neat Item written in a simple, clean format. When Eternal Selach was still in your sandbox, I had long believed that it was supposed to be a supplement or a tale to I.S.
- I have noticed that the previous iteration of I.S. had been completely removed in favor of the rewrite, which boasts a multiple compartment of separate documents kind of gimmick. This seems like a loss to me. I enjoyed the original, especially the witty end to it.
- While it's not mine to nitpick, the de-facto site logo has been updated and we have new classes for div blocks instead of the clunky style=""; chunk previously used. Perhaps you'll consider changing ;)
All in all, I enjoy the rewrite, but it cannot be Imperial Sharks. It will never sit with me as an Item - more of a detailed supplementary tale to it. So while I am still upvoting, it is because I will treat the rewrite 'as is', if it will be shipped to a new page and the original returns to this one, my upvotes will remain, because upvotes are plentiful and free. Like green peas, or love.